In honor of Arrow‘s first season concluding this week, I thought I’d pit two of the show’s male stars against each other in our latest Who’d You Rather poll. Given that Colton Haynes will most likely be Stephen Amell’s sidekick next season, it was only appropriate to pit this Batman and Robin-type relationship against each other.

First up is Stephen Amell. This Canadian actor just oozes man. The 32-year-old actor guest starred on numerous shows including Queer as Folk, The Vampire Diaries, 90210 and New Girl to name a few. My favorite was his role on Showtime’s Hung where he played a male prostitute. Lots of gratuitous shirtless scenes. But by far, his biggest role to date is playing Oliver Green on Arrow. The pilot gave the network its highest ratings in years. Those titillating promo posters certainly did the trick. Amell is a recent newlywed, marrying former ANTM alum Cassandra Whitehead.

Next up is 24-year-old Colton Haynes. Haynes started out his career by modeling for Abercrombie & Fitch, Ralph Lauren and JC Penney. Prior to landing his role as Roy Harper on The CW show, Colton played a werewolf twice on ABC’s The Gates and MTV’s Teen Wolf. He’s also appeared in a couple of episodes of The Hills, music videos for Leona Lewis and My Chemical Romance. Check out photos of Colton and Stephen below and cast your vote on Who’d You Rather.

check out the photos after the jump

It’s been a couple of weeks since I pitted Charlie Hunnam against Alex Pettyfer. Thought I’d have a little fun with my latest Who’d You Rather match-up. If don’t understand the post title, clearly you’ve never heard of the awesomeness that is Macklemore & Ryan Lewis. The Seattle duo’s breakout hit, “Thrift Shop” has sold over 2.2 million copies and viewed more than 275 million times on YouTube. Their latest clip, “Can’t Hold Us” is even more epic.

Not many guys can pull of seemingly random put-together pieces from vintage stores and make it look hot. But for some reason, these two hipster poster boys pull it off and do it with massive sex appeal. I have to say, Macklemore isn’t typically my type, but there’s just something about him. Both guys not only have that white boy hip hop swagger going for them, but both are huge LGBT allies which makes them even more attractive. Their “Same Love” music video is a must-see.

If you don’t know who’s who? Macklemore, born Ben Haggerty, is the 29-year-old redhead, while Ryan Lewis is the 25-year-old brunette. Check out photos of them below and cast your vote.

check out more photos after the jump

Both hail from the United Kingdom and both are celebrating birthdays today (April 10). In honor of their special day, I thought I’d pit these two studs against each other in our latest Who’d You Rather battle. They may be a decade apart, but these two are equally sexy and handsome. After checking out the following evidence (shirtless photos), be sure to cast your verdict in the poll. Who do you want to give the birthday bumps to?

Alex Pettyfer made a huge splash in 2011. The 23-year-old actor starred in three films- I Am Number Four (Dianna Agron), Beastly (Vanessa Hudgens) and In Time (Justin Timberlake). Personally, I didn’t get the hype until I saw him practically bottoming for Matthew McConnaughey during a stripping tutorial in Magic Mike. Instantly, I became a fan. He can next be seen later this year in Butler starring Robin Williams and James Marsden. Pettyfer also modeled for Burberry in 2008-2009.

Charlie Hunnam gained a huge gay following after appearing in the UK version of Queer as Folk. Now, the 33-year-old is best known for playing Jax Teller on Sons of Anarchy. His film credits include Nicholas Nickleby (Anne Hathaway), Cold Mountain (Jude Law), and Children of Men (Clive Owen). Hunnam will headline this summer’s sci-fi flim, Pacific Rim. Charlie was previously married to actress Katharine Towne but divorced in 2002.

check out photos after the jump and vote

This might be a tad sacrilegious, but who doesn’t like courting a bit of controversy ;) Since Easter was just a few days ago and the History Channel’s The Bible miniseries ended it’s spectacular run with boffo ratings, I thought this match up was a bit inappropriate. Let’s get to know more about these two gentlemen who played Jesus Christ.

First up is Diogo Morgado. The 33-year-old actor is one of Portugal’s top actors with a career spanning over 16 years in top tv, film and stage productions. Along with speaking Portuguese, he also speaks English and French. Who doesn’t love a multilingual tongue? YUM. He’ll next appear in the 2013 Hollywood production of Red Butterfly. Morgado has a son named Santiago.

James Caviezel appeared in numerous movies such as G.I. Jane, The Rock and Pay It Forward before landing the lead role in Mel Gibson’s The Passion of the Christ. After playing Jesus Christ, Caviezel wasn’t able to translate his new-found notoriety to land major roles. In all seriousness, I could barely recognize anything on his IMDB credits worth mentioning. The 44-year-old actor will next appear in The Tomb co-starring Arnold Schwarzenegger and Sylvester Stallone. Caviezel who is a devout Catholic has been married since 1996 and has two adopted children from China.

check out photos after the jump and vote

There was a time when I was addicted to home improvement shows. My drug of choice… TLC’s Trading Spaces hosted by Paige Davis. It was reality crack. I’m sure I wasn’t alone. Remember the looks on homeowners’ faces when they found out that Hildi Santo-Tomas was the designer assigned to their home? Their horrified looks were everything.

Had HGTV’s Kitchen Cousins been around in the day, I’m sure I would’ve been glued to this show instead. Both Anthony Carrino and John Colaneri aren’t too bad to look at. In fact, some publications have likened the show to soft core HGTV porn. I don’t blame them. These Italian cousins are beefy man candy. Plus, who doesn’t love a man who knows how to drill and hammer *wink*.

So what is Kitchen Cousins all about? It follows Carrino and Colaneri who run a New Jersey-based family construction company that focuses on turning mediocre kitchens into masterpieces. The two even managed to snag the goddess Vanessa Williams on the show. Without further ado, check out Anthony and John below. Don’t forget to cast your vote on who’d you rather see underneath your kitchen sink ;)

see more pictures after the jump

After seeing paparazzi shots of Mark-Paul Gosselaar on the beach filming his new show Franklin & Bash, I was inspired to do a Who’d You Rather: Saved By The Bell edition. Now, we can all walk a mile in Kelly Kapowski’s shoes. Choosing between these two is no easy task. I can’t believe we haven’t pitted these two against each other yet. It’s well documented that Mario Lopez still has a bangin’ body, but Gosselaar isn’t looking too shabby himself. Time has been kind to both these studs.

Since his days playing AC Slater on the classic teen sitcom, Lopez has mostly delved in the reality genre. The 39-year-old carved a niche as the go-to person to host a show. Lopez’s hosting credits include Extra, America’s Best Dance Crew and The X Factor. Before hosting, he competed on the third season of Dancing With The Stars where he was the runner-up. Mario also fronted his own reality docu-series, Mario Lopez: Saved By The Baby on VH1. My favorite post-SBTB gig hands down is his guest starring stint on Nip/Tuck. That shower scene was everything ;) Lopez is currently married to Courtney Mazza. The two have a daughter named Gia Francesca and are expecting their second child this September.

Unlike his Saved By The Bell co-star Lopez, the former Zack Morris has mainly stayed in the scripted genre. The 39-year-old actor has multiple television credits. Gosselaar starred in NYPD Blue from 2001-2005. Currently, he’s co-headlining TNT’s Franklin & Bash with Breckin Meyer. Like Mario, Mark-Paul has showed off his juicy butt. You can Google those beautiful screencaps from his TNT show and a guest spot on Showtime’s Weeds. He’s also guest starred on Law & Order: Special Victims Unit, Happy Endings and Rizzoli & Isles. Mark-Paul is currently married to Catriona McGinn. The two are expecting their first child in September like Lopez. How coincidental is that? Gosselaar has two other children from a previous marriage.

Without further ado, check out the guys from their days on Saved By The Bell to today. Don’t forget to cast your vote at the end.

check out the pictures after the jump

Did you watch the premiere of The Following on FOX this week? The serial killer drama lived up to its hype, especially the gory violence. I was definitely squeamish a certain points. If you haven’t watched it yet, I won’t spoil things too much, but I highly recommend it. Hopefully, the show can maintain the quality of action and suspense in the pilot episode throughout the season. Since I’m already hooked on the show, I thought I’d pit the show’s gay couple against each other in our latest Who’d You Rather battle. May the hottest man win.

First up is 24-year-old Nico Tortorella (left). I first noticed the Illinois native when he briefly starred in The CW’s ill-fated The Beautiful Life back in 2009. The former male model soon found work on both television and film. Tortorella appeared in ABC Family’s Make It or Break It and in the fourth installment of the Scream horror franchise. Nico obviously impressed Scream screenwriter Kevin Williamson. He hired Tortorella again for his new creation, The Following.

Adan Canto (right) is an actor hailing from Acuña, Coahuila, Mexico. The 31-year-old Latin heartthrob appeared mostly in Mexican films before landing his role on FOX’s The Following. Canto made his film debut at the age of nine in Like Water For Chocolate. In addition to acting, Adan is a professional singer and plays the guitar and piano.

Now that you have a brief background on each stud, check out a few photos before picking Who’d You Rather. Not trying to sway the vote in any particular way, but I love me some Tortorella. I picked him as my Man Crush a few years ago. Watching him on The Following has inspired me to update that post in the near future. Enough campaigning, check out both guys below.

check out pics after the jump

It’s been quite a while since we did a Who’d You Rather post, so I thought I get the ball rolling with these two hotties for the first boy battle of 2013. With the Box Office success of Texas Chainsaw 3D, I thought I thought it’d be a great time to highlight the leading man from the film: Trey Songz. Although I haven’t seen it, in one of the production stills of the movie, the 28-year-old is shirtless and looking fine. The actor/singer has a really hot body and I love his tattoos.

Inspired by Songz’s tattoos, I thought I’d find another black, tattooed hottie to put him up against (…and my mind just went into the gutter :p..). I chose 26-year-old Devin Thomas, a super former NFL football player who retired from playing the sport professionally in 2012 to avoid any permanent injuries and so he focus on settling down with his wife. Both are super handsome and have insanely hot bodies with the only difference being that Thomas (given that he was a football player) is a bit beefier and has more tattoos.

Good luck with this one because as I write this, I still haven’t even decided. They’re both super sexy and have their unique selling points (actor/singer vs. football player, etc.).

Pictures & poll after the jump…