Filed under: Donovan, TV Shows
Author: Donovan
Date: Nov 9, 2012
Tonight’s X Factor results show BLEW MY MIND. Not because of the bottom two or who was eliminated. Rather, it was a move made by the FOX program, going where no other singing competition has gone before. Believe it or not, Mario Lopez and Khloe Kardashian revealed how ALL the acts ranked based on viewer votes. I know the UK version releases the results of every week at the end of the competition, but never as it’s taking place. This is an ABSOLUTELY brilliant move by Simon Cowell. People are definitely going to be tuning in on elimination nights to see how their favorites are faring.
One Direction kicked off the evening with a live performance of “Live While We’re Young“, complete with oversize balloons. Personally, I loved the set with London’s signature red phone booths stacked on each other. Very British and very fun. This segued into the boy band pimping out their Pepsi commercial featuring Drew Brees. 1D showed up later to perform their newest track, the stripped down ballad, “Little Things“, which I absolutely adore. Cowell certainly hit the goldmine with these five lads.
Now onto to the results. During the first set of reveals, Arin Ray, Paige Thomas, Diamond White, Vino Alan, Jennel Garcia and Emblem3 were sent to safety. After One Direction’s performance, the next group advancing to next week’s show were Carly Rose Sonenclar, Tate Stevens and Beatrice Miller, making Britney the first of the mentors to have her entire group safe. Simon was the next judge to have all his acts through with LYRIC 145 and Fifth Harmony advancing. CeCe Frey and Jason Brock were left standing, making them the bottom two this week.
I’m surprised she picked this song from Burlesque and not a Christina Aguilera tune. Frey’s cover of “Ain’t No Other Man” is one of her better ones on the show. I don’t think she’s going tonight, but I wasn’t overly impressed with her Save Me Song. That said, it was light years better than “Eye of the Tiger” or last week’s trainwreck.
Bold choice choosing this Bonnie Tyler classic. Vocally, he was more on pitch than CeCe Frey. It was definitely in his wheelhouse and true to what he’s performed throughout his run on the show.
Obviously, LA Reid and Demi Lovato chose to save their acts. Surprisingly, Brit sends home CeCe, while Simon picks Jason as the one to go, leaving it in deadlock. Not surprisingly, Jason is sent home. While I loved him, I couldn’t see America embracing him. Loved his exit speech giving a shout out to the gays and Japan. LOL. Here’s hoping he gets his dream of landing a television show. I’d definitely watch him and his harem of Asian boys parade all over San Francisco as they sing diva ballads ;)
Now, for the best part of the show- the results of the rest of America’s votes are revealed. In ascending order, here’s how it went down.
While I agree Tate did well this week, I’m half-shocked he was No. 1. I knew he’d do well, but the top vote getter??? Middle America may not have won the election, but they won on X Factor… this week. Also surprising was how low Jennel Garcia was. I’m really afraid for her. Vino Alan has no business being that high and Emblem3 and Fifth Harmony should’ve been higher than Diamond White. How about you? What did you think of tonight’s elimination and the vote rankings? Sound off below.
Just in case you wanted to see One Direction’s performances, here they are.
Laurine
November 8th, 2012 at 10:39 pm
I was also surprised with how low Beatrice and Lyric 145 were. I definitely though they’d be higher than Paige. I don’t like Paige much; I think she was the weakest voice in the competition. Demi’s group doesn’t seem to be doing well, so this should be a wake up call for her.
Evan
November 8th, 2012 at 11:02 pm
I agree that Demi needs to get with it! Paige has the weakest voice and CeCe REALLY needs to reinvent herself if she wants to stay in the competition, as much as I love her. At this point in the competition, I feel like Carly Rose should win.
Gabriel
November 8th, 2012 at 11:50 pm
Cece sounded like a drowning cat as she sang for her life. She has gots to go!
CT
November 9th, 2012 at 1:07 am
CeCe gives too much bitch face, I can’t see America embracing her, she doesn’t have that likability factor. And Tate Stevens has an advantage considering he’s not splitting the votes with anyone, he’s the only country act. Pretty much everyone else is splitting the vote with someone
meh
November 9th, 2012 at 1:51 am
I really dislike the US version compared to the UK version. From the hosting (Chloe is just awful), to the reveals being broken up into segments, and to the standings – I think that they are trying too hard to distance themselves from the other singing competition shows.
With that said, it’ll be interesting to see how Tate does as the competition progresses. I can’t believe that he’s in the number one position.
HarryR
November 9th, 2012 at 3:41 am
Actually, I’m not surprised that Tate Stevens was as high as top. He’s the only country singer. There are a whole lot of county music fans that watch these competition shows. County singers generally do very well, often winning. Agree with Cowell’s surprise that Emblem3 was 6th, expecting them to be in the top 3. Dislike Cece, both her singing, which is uneven, and her attitude, which is an expectation that she is destined to win so we should just award her now rather than wasting her time by drawing out the competition.
Road
November 9th, 2012 at 5:18 am
Fifth Harmony did the best last night!!! damn! and dafuq @ Beatrice’s placement!! you people’s taste suck!
justin
November 9th, 2012 at 7:36 am
emblem 3 needed to be at the bottom with arin i dont understand why people like a bunch of douchebags that can barely sing. if gary barlow was a judge he would be hating on them like he hates on ryland. lyric 145 should have been higher and fifth harmony too.
hizi
November 9th, 2012 at 8:07 am
OK homorazzi….are we done bashing Miss White????? Its just plain stupid to hate on a 13 year old girl who has an AMAZING voice AND is likable…*cough*CarlyRose*cough*
cece lover
November 9th, 2012 at 11:03 am
i hate carly cause she acts too mature for her age that i love beatrice miller she a down to earth sakter girl and also a normal teenager who had fun with her own age. Cece she got real talent but her stage presence doesn’t shine. Paige is pathetic. But still voting for cece or beatrice
David
November 9th, 2012 at 11:28 am
Carly Rose doesn’t need a big production. She sings with her heart on her sleeve. She may not say much but once she starts singing she leaves it all out on the stage. I love Fifth Harmony, they are sweet, super talented girls. The way their voices blend is just amazing. Jennel should’ve definitely been in the top 3. Vino? Really? He’s good but not that good. As far as Emblem3, all I can say is I’m very thankful for DVR. I’ve given them a fair chance but just the sight of them makes me cringe. There are enough douchebags on t.v.
David
November 9th, 2012 at 11:32 am
…also, love you Jason. Cece should’ve gone home.
jimmymackey
November 9th, 2012 at 12:28 pm
Jason Brock is the true tragedy here simply because the show (and America) is looking for an iconic image of a pop/rock star, which Jason’s personality didn’t fit. He was true to himself, which is commendable, but in the end he met with ridicule. So sad he wasn’t judged on his talent alone. My wife and I haven’t watched the last two episodes together since I started catching the show the next morning, before I go to work. With the Auto Hop feature on the Hopper DVR I got from my DISH coworker, I can watch commercial free. DISH gives me the ability to get ready for work and get done watching The X Factor before I have to leave in the morning, which is so convenient for my tight schedule.
rogelio
November 9th, 2012 at 7:07 pm
it’s funny they were looking for someone who will sell records not only in America though… that guy can only sell records in the US… the only way a country star can sell records abroad is if they crossover to pop, like shania or taylor… country music is plain boring…
@jorgealison
November 9th, 2012 at 7:34 pm
I’m not shocked as shocked to know Tate is Number 1 as I am shocked for LYRIC142 and Jennel’s position. Doesn’t even make sense for me.
Wes
November 10th, 2012 at 6:55 am
I know it wasn’t a big hit, but didn’t Duets (with Kelly Clarkson, John Legend, Robin Thicke and Jennifer Nettles) also show the rankings? I could be mistaken. I gave up on that show before the finale.