Filed under: Donovan, TV Shows
Author: Donovan
Date: Dec 20, 2012
It’s finally here. After all the auditions, boot camp, judges’ homes and double eliminations it’s the big night where the Top 3 give it all they have. Thank God. I’m not sure I can endure another week of the X Factor. I really hope Simon makes even more drastic changes for next year to challenge The Voice and American Idol. That said, I really did enjoy some aspects this year. Particularly the revealing of the rankings on results night was a welcome addition.
For the final night of competition, the remaining acts sang three songs each- a memorable song from the series, a celebrity duet and their $5 million song. Speaking of the duets, clearly the show has lost a bit of its pull. Last year, Avril Lavigne, Alanis Morissette and R. Kelly joined the Final 3 for duets. This year, Cowell got LeAnn Rimes, Little Big Town and judge Demi Lovato to duo with the contestants. No disrespect but definitely less star wattage. Meanwhile on The Voice, Rihanna, Kelly Clarkson, The Killers, Bruno Mars and even Lavigne popped up for the star-studded finale.
Before the Final 3 battled it out, a group performance with X Factor’s Top 13 kicked things off. Simon Cowell gave a few words dedicating the number to the victims of the Sandy Hook shootings. Though well-intentioned and sentimental in its own right, I couldn’t help but reliving The Voice’s moving “Hallelujah” tribute. The emotional performance had the judges and contestants holding cards with names of those who perished. If you haven’t watched it, you simply have to. I’m tearing up just thinking about it. Without further ado, let’s get to tonight’s performances.
Song: “Feeling Good” by Nina Simone
Song: “How Do I Live” by LeAnn Rimes
Song: “Hallelujah” by Leonard Cohen
For having to share a stage with LeAnn Rimes alone, Carly Rose deserves the title. Obviously, I don’t want to accuse someone of having a substance abuse problem, but clearly Rimes was a bit unhinged. What happened to the talented teen that originally sang “How Do I Live?” It’s like Rimes and Sonenclar never rehearsed together. LeAnn was all over the place. Props to Carly Rose for making the best of it. The pint-sized singer filled in the gaps when needed. I loved Britney Spears’ reaction while watching the trainwreck. She probably was thinking, “Girl, I’ve been there,” as she sympathetically stared at LeAnn. LOL
If Carly Rose wins tomorrow night it’ll be due to her phenomenal rendition of “Hallelujah“. After almost being derailed by LeAnn “homewrecking” Rimes, she wowed with her last performance. My only complaint (due to no fault of her own), was the fact I now associate this song with the Sandy Hook shootings. I’ll never be able to not visualize The Voice’s moving tribute when I hear the song from now on.
Song: “Anything Goes” by Randy Houser
Song: “Pontoon” by Little Big Town
Song: “Tomorrow” by Chris Young
If Tate wins tomorrow it’s due to vote splitting between Sonenclar and Fifth Harmony. He’s been solid all season long, but tonight he didn’t have that one defining magical moment. If he had one memorable moment, it was his adorably awkward dancing during his celebrity duet with Little Big Town. If I was in a cowboy bar in Texas, that’s what I would want to see… not on the X Factor stage. That said, dude is going to have a solid post-show career. There is no way Simon isn’t signing him. The Brit wants some of that lucrative country music money. Hee Haw.
Song: “Anything Could Happen” by Ellie Goulding
Song: “Give Your Heart A Break” by Demi Lovato
Song: “Let It Be” by The Beatles
It kinda sucked that the girls’ best performance was last week and their second best outing was performed last week as well. Simon had no choice but to get them to cover the Ellie Goulding track again. With the star-making moment so fresh, a few things were switched up. Normani and Ally lost their solos and some spoken word intro was added. Overall, it was good but not as amazing as last week.
For their duet, Demi became the sixth member of the group. At first listen, I thought Lovato bombed. I came around when I watched it a second time. That said, all the 5H girls have better voices than the X Factor judge. Ouch, but you know it’s true.
After Sonenclar sang “Hallelujah“, I thought she had it in the bag. Thankfully, Simon picked The Beatles classic as their final song. Each girl delivered an impeccable vocal during their solo. Camilla rocked it with that whole adlib near the end. It reminded me of early Nelly Furtado.
I think Tate will come in third with Carly Rose and Fifth Harmony dueling it out for the $5 million contract. Personally, I hope the girl group takes it, but I think Carly is going to edge them out, giving Britney that win she was promised when she signed her contract ;) Pretty much the order the Final 3 came out during the Sandy Hook tribute performance. Speaking of which, see it below.
What do you think of the final performances? Who do you think will win? Who should win? What was your favorite performance? Sound off below.
Slade
December 20th, 2012 at 3:20 am
I personally dont know how Fifth Harmony made it this far. They are the mayors or lame-ville!
Evan
December 20th, 2012 at 4:13 am
I liked Fifth Harmony’s version of “Anything Could Happen” better this week than last, and I also have to disagree with saying every girl of Fifth Harmony is better than Lovato. I thought Demi worked it and proved to everyone why she was asked to be a judge/mentor this year.
As a whole, I can’t see Carly not winning (she is still trending on Twitter HOURS after the show has ended), but I would really like to see Fifth Harmony get a record deal as well. They are a lot of fun and have a lot of potential.
bruin
December 20th, 2012 at 4:21 am
Donovan did you vote again this week? I actually called in for the first time to vote for fifth harmony. i really want the underdog to win and totally in love w camille!! carly will go far even without winning this competition but i definitely do want to hear music from this potential spice girls -esque group. and yeah ur predictions are right at the end
Homegirl No5
December 20th, 2012 at 6:54 am
Not a Carly fan. But poor girl, having to be paired with LeAnn Rimes. And 30-something LeAnn trying to out-sing the innocent young girl! Even if Carly still wins, how traumatizing to have to be on stage with a crazy, homewrecking drunk!
That poor, poor young girl!
Homegirl No5
December 20th, 2012 at 6:57 am
And when I heard that Demi Lovato was about to hit the stage with Fifth Harmony for her own song, as decided on by Simon Cowell, I felt bad for her. It was obvious she was about to be out-sang in her own song, and indeed she was. Ouch!
Love Fifth Harmony, though! Voted for them 5 times. :)
Wes
December 20th, 2012 at 10:35 am
I prefer Carly but think Fifth Harmony should and probably will win. Let’s be honest, Carly and Tate will get contracts after this. I assume Simon will also sign Fifth Harmony regardless who wins, but their chances increase more with the win. I also feel like they were doing their best to pimp out Fifth Harmony last night. They sang without a doubt their most crowd pleasing song of the season, even though it was from last week. They sang with Demi, a judge. (Poor, poor Carly got stuck with a trainwreck that most younger voters won’t even know or will want to know after that performance.) and finally, they closed the show in typical show pimping fashion.
One overwhelming complaint I have about the X-Factor comes from the fact that the judges are mentors. Complete lack of honestly. At this point in the show, everyone but Demi has something to gain so they say nothing but fluff. No real criticism. The X Factor made some improvements this year, but I feel like they need to make a few more if they come back for Season 3.
erica smith
December 20th, 2012 at 10:54 am
fifth harmony should win
LOVE ME
December 20th, 2012 at 11:41 am
Slade u are so fucked up
Tyson
December 20th, 2012 at 1:17 pm
@Wes, I agree completely. What needs to happen is a separation between the mentors and the judges. Maybe one set of celebrities can be the judges, while some other names could tackle the teaching of these acts. The way it is right now is just irritating.
I still see tate winning (Idol’s Scotty Mcreery win, ahoy!) but I’d love for Fifth Harmony to clinch it.
P.S. Carly’s facial expression during that last performance with Rimes was too funny for words.
Paul
December 20th, 2012 at 2:31 pm
Hell no, Demi is a sensational vocalist who held her own most definitely, hey at least she sang unlike another judge
Andrew
December 20th, 2012 at 4:50 pm
I’m so happy I did not watch this season. Season 1 was ok, this one is just over-produced and filled with unnecessary drama. X-Factor UK all the way!
justin
December 20th, 2012 at 7:13 pm
X-factor UK was really good. this season of x-factor US not so much, for some reason that tribute in the beginning didnt feel right it was off in some way.
carly rose something about her annoys me, she pretentious for some reason like there is something fake about her. i wonder if x-factor knows of the curse of the feeling good song since the majority if not everybody who sings that song in these competitions either goes home or is in danger of going home. the voice versions of hallelujah was so much better and carly rose her version was lacking i dont know not my favorite.
tate stevens did the same thing he always did boring.
fifth harmony would probably be the only act that i would want to see more music from.
so happy that idiot LA reid is not coming back yay. now get rid of khloe and make x-factor us more like x-factor uk.
Gie
December 20th, 2012 at 9:05 pm
You guys are delusional!! I’m sure fifth harmony won’t win the X Factor!!
fprex scam
January 14th, 2013 at 9:42 am
If you are looking for a scam forex site, this is the place for you. Here you find all forex scammers!