Filed under: Adam, Sports & Health
Author: Adam
Date: Nov 24, 2010
Tweet
Huge Breakthrough.
A recent study on a drug called Truvada has been found to significantly cut the odds of infection in gay and bisexual men who engage in what we so euphemistically call “risky sexual practices”… we’re talking a level of protection of 73% for those taking it daily. SEVENTY THREE PER CENT. By no means is Truvada the new condom or the be-all-end-all of discoveries but this is an undeniably huge discovery in the world of HIV prevention for men who sleep with men.
The international study comprised of 2,500 men in six different countries (Brazil, Ecuador, Peru, South Africa, Thailand and the United States) and compared the HIV contraction rates of gay men who self-reportedly had sex with multiple partners and were inconsistent with their condom use: basically, Johnny-Q-Gay. Half the subjects were given a placebo and the other half the pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP): Truvada, and there were clear results. After just one year, 64 out of 1,248 placebo participants had contracted HIV while only 36 out of 1,251 of those taking Truvada did. Only a year in, the results have been published in the New England Journal of Medicine as a boon for the current HIV/AIDS epidemic.
Where antiretroviral drugs have been typically seen as a means of preventing the progression of HIV to AIDS and to dampen the infection, Truvada is proving to be a shockingly effective tool in preventing the contraction of the virus: essentially stopping the disease before it even starts. The lead researcher of the study- a Dr. Robert Grant of the Gladstone Institute of Virology and Immunology in California- supported his finding by explaining that instead of just handing out the drugs (or placebos) to the subjects and letting them run wild, they were offered state of the art prevention methods including testing, counseling and education to ensure a balance between the studied men. Basically, where one might argue the seemingly not huge difference in the numbers of those transmitting the disease could be due to something as random as maturity or knowledge on the subject etc., the study truly attempted to equate the random men as thoroughly as possible to ensure the results reflected the role of the drug.
Still, the drug isn’t perfect. As with most medication it requires consistent use: once a day. While we might roll our eyes at the thought of a daily pill being simple to remember, detractors of the study argue that: “Men who engage in ‘risky sexual behavior’ are less likely to be regular with their dosage.” Personally, I’m a bit offended by the assumption that one equates to the other, but it is a relevant issue that the pill must be taken every day. Though, the drug was still found to be at its most effective so long as the regularity of consumption was at least 90% of the time… that sounds safer than birth control to me, but what the hell do I know ;)
Furthermore- and this won’t exactly seem like a huge downfall to us mo’s- the drug has only been tested thus far on men who sleep with men. Heterosexual testing and testing with women is still pending so this is not a panacea thus far. This “PrEP research” as it’s being called, has received a huge boost by these results and will hopefully- according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control- be used to find an effective and indiscriminating tool to battle this global epidemic. Finally, the researchers make it very clear Truvada is not a prevention tool for any other form of STDs: this one affects HIV transmission only.
Personally, this news is pretty amazing. Constantly working to support and donating to HIV/AIDS research causes often seems fruitless as the disease continues on into nearly its 30th year with still 7,000 people a day contracting HIV. So, when something comes along that shakes up the playing field this vigorously, I get pretty excited. Though I’m one of those die-hard condom boys that has never tricked a guy into dating me long enough that the talk of going without has even come up ethereally, the idea that there’s a drug that need only be swallowed with a bit of water daily that will even more greatly increase my likelihood to stay negative is a life-changing one. Clearly, the side effects need to be fully considered- not mentioned if there are any at all in the research I did- and the availability isn’t exactly at your local pharmacy today, but in the future, this is definitely a discovery that’s going to change the way we think about this virus. Go Science!
Dan Bate
November 24th, 2010 at 7:25 pm
Great article Adam. Sad to think that even though participants in the study were probably more educated than most about infection, 4% still contracted it. Much better odds than without, but still.
Adam
November 25th, 2010 at 2:39 am
Thanks Dan!
Good point, regardless of being placebo or no, these guys did have a large amount of knowledge, support and info about this issue and still as many as 4% contracted… “Complicated” doesn’t even begin to describe this issue!
Colby
November 25th, 2010 at 4:11 pm
That’s a really cool new development! And very exciting. Although, one wonders whether a development like this encourages risk-taking, as in “hey I’m on ‘the pill’, I don’t need no stinkin’ condoms!”, in the same way many fear today that HIV/AIDS’ current status as an arguably-manageable disease (rather than the death sentence it was at first) creates a climate of carelessness and encourages risk-taking.
Obviously, anything that reduces the rate of transmission is an amazing development, but only if it doesn’t concurrently change people’s mindsets in a way that increases risky behaviour and therefore transmission, thus neutralizing any gains…or reductions, maybe.
Was that part of the study? Maybe there should have been a third control group. It’s entirely possible that the rate of transmission in the placebo group might also have increased due to a change in behaviour, i.e. increased risk-taking based on a perceived level of protection.
And once-a-day, every-day can be onerous. I can’t even remember to take my multi-vitamin every morning, for God’s sake.
Adam
November 25th, 2010 at 4:26 pm
Somehow, I would like to think if it was a pill you were expecting to help prevent contraction of HIV you’d take it a bit more serious than a multivitamin… maybe go as crazy as put an alarm on your iPhone to remind..?
Personally, I see that kind of argument akin to teaching abstinence rather than proper condom use because “teaching of the benefits of condoms makes kids think it’s okay to just have sex with anyone etc”. I doubt someone with even half a brain who WANT to stay negative will say “hey, 73% chance i won’t get it? who needs a condom/to ask about their status”… 73% isn’t exactly a for sure deal by ANY means.
Colby
November 25th, 2010 at 10:13 pm
Oh, I disagree strongly, Adam. The groups were gay men who were laissez-faire with condom use already (or as you call them, Johnny-Q Gay), so already taking pretty serious chances. You think that’s a group that’s going to go “oh my God I have to take my once-a-day-73%-chance-of-stopping-the-transmission-of-HIV pill!!!! Stop everything!”. No, they’re going to go “meh, I’ll take it tomorrow. Maybe. I’m sure it’s fine.”
And I think you’re reaching by comparing it to teaching abstinence as THE effective means of preventing transmission. Abstinence is unrealistic. Condom use isn’t. Just ask…oh, I don’t know…YOU!
Adam
November 26th, 2010 at 7:15 am
Hmmmm I think we’re gonna have to agree to disa…. nah, let’s just both agree you’re wrong colbs.
First off, the guys were “inconsistent” with condom use. Do you know what constitutes “consistent”? 100% or 0%. And, other than myself, I’ve never met a single person in my life who’s at that 100% mark, and, except for those few die-hard bare backers hititn’ the 0% one hundred percent of the time, every gay male in the middle is taking “pretty serious chances” as you put it… I would argue that not every gay we know is “taking pretty serious chances” with their lives/health… but, that’s just my opinion there, you’re absolutely in your right to judge that they are.
Second, for the LARGE part, every time i’ve heard of a friend not using a condom it’s been a drunken/drug addled/moment of passion didn’t-want-to stop-it decision right at the moment of penetration: it wasn’t something they sat down and consciously decided with much forethought (setting aside those I know who often and purposefully don’t use condoms that it of course). Taking medicine daily (which typically occurs in the morning before work for most, or at night while brushing teeth etc.) isn’t usually an after-dropping-e-and-finding-one’s-self-in-a-backroom-at-the-Eagle thing to do. Therefore equating the slipping on of a condom mid-fuck to taking medication at ANY point during the 1440 minutes of the day seems a bit spurious, sugar ;)
Finally, CLEARLY i’m not teaching abstinence as “the” tool to prevent transmition silly. Maybe my thick sarcasm in which I compared your argument to “abstinence preachers” directly AFTER I made fun of your argument wasn’t obvious…? I’ll slow it down for ya: saying that a study which demonstrates Truvada to be a means of REDUCING (note: not eliminating) HIV transmition (by a percent MUCH less than using condoms) means people will say “f-that” to wrapping it up is like saying if a guy heard douching could vaguely decrease the chance of catching the virus he’d run to his drawer and throw out all Trojans and Truvadas. Sure, there’s always those few crazed exceptions out there, but the majority of guys aren’t that insane and without reason: again, though, maybe I just give us more credit.
…don’t worry, you don’t have to reply if you agree now ;)
bruin
November 28th, 2010 at 5:54 am
yay adam. you can add me onto your 100% condom. it’s only going off when there’s a ring on my finger. and also, abstinence is unrealistic since we are human beings and sex is as normal as eating, breathing, drinking. great post on the new update!
Adam
November 28th, 2010 at 1:05 pm
I guess I’m not alone then bruin!
Waiting till a ring eh? Beyonce would be proud: I don’t think I have that patience haha but till a treating and clear commitment is made I’m in the condom boat with ya!
Thanks for the comment!
sam
December 12th, 2010 at 8:24 am
Israel has made a breakthrough,, they had got the formula for kiiling the HIV virus gene untouching the un-infected cells,
hebrew university, Jerusalem