Filed under: Donovan, Music, TV Shows
Author: Donovan
Date: Nov 30, 2012
When NBC announced it was planning on remaking the seminal musical for the small screen, I nearly had a heart attack. One on hand, I was excited to see what the Smash producers would have in store for us. On the other hand, The Sound of Music is truly one of my favorite things and tinkering around with a classic is difficult endeavor. I have faith though that Craig Zadan and Neil Meron won’t let me down. After all, they did work on the film versions of Hairspray and Chicago.
“It isn’t our intention to produce a remake of the movie version of ‘The Sound of Music’ – that would be artistic blasphemy,” Craig Zadan says in a statement. “What we want to do, instead, is to give audiences a completely fresh experience of this great Tony Award-winning stage musical in the form of a classic television event, combined with the spontaneity of a live performance. And all of the actors will be singing live; there will be no lip-synching to pre-recordings.”
As with any great musical, casting is key. If you don’t have the right person playing the lead parts, you’re up sh*t creek without a paddle. Maria Von Trapp is definitely one of the most iconic roles in musical history. Trying to follow in the footsteps of Julie Andrews is a tall order. Let’s face it. Anyone who’s cast in NBC’s remake is going to have a few naysayers. Personally, I love their choice. Find out who it is below.

She’s already portrayed a Dorothy-like character in her Wizard of Oz-inspired “Blown Away” music video, and now she’s going to tell us that the hills are alive with the sound of music. It’s none other than Carrie Underwood. The 29-year-old is slated to star in the three-hour special slated to air in late 2013.
“We’re thrilled to be presenting the Broadway version of The Sound of Music live,” producers Craig Zadan and Neil Meron said in a statement. “Having Carrie Underwood as the star brings it to a new generation who will fall in love with it for the first time as many millions of people already have. It’s a particular joy to us as producers to see this amazing artist stretch into new territory with this classic musical.”
There’s no doubt Carrie has the vocal talent to tackle the role, but will she have the acting chops to pull off some of the more emotional parts. The new adaptation will be based on the 1959 Broadway show instead of the film starring Julie Andrews and Christopher Plummer. That said, their version will feature songs from the movie along with additional music from the Broadway show that theater buffs will appreciate.
What do you think of Carrie’s casting? Do you think the country superstar can pull off playing an Austrian nun? Who would’ve you cast? Sound off below.
DL
November 30th, 2012 at 5:58 pm
NO. Just NO. I don’t care if they shoved the entire original movie cast into a time machine and re-shot the whole thing shot for shot. NO. Leave this alone. The Sound of Music is the movie of my childhood. Stop. Remaking. Everything.
Ryan
November 30th, 2012 at 6:08 pm
DL, chill, they’re not remaking the movie. =) It will be really interesting to see how this turns out, how exciting for Underwood to tackle such a role!
MauiJim
November 30th, 2012 at 8:00 pm
This will be different from the film on so many levels. We’ll hear the Countess sing and see the show in a very different way.
Peter
December 1st, 2012 at 12:39 am
I’d watch it to compare, but if I don’t like her voice in the role I’d turn it off. She has a voice nothing like Julie’s: no vibrato, not particularly sweet-sounding and certainly not the range. I can’t imagine what the producer’s were thinking (except about her good looks), but I’d give her a chance. Julie will always be Maria.
Matt
December 1st, 2012 at 9:25 pm
Just be glad they didn’t choose Christina Floptina.
Perry
December 1st, 2012 at 9:26 pm
To the first comment – Stop remaking everything? The film you hold with such high regard is a remake.
I’m Personally ECSTATIC that Carrie Underwood will be taking on this amazing role. I’m excited to see this musical with a new interpretation. The only thing I’m upset about is having to wait a whole year!
jd
December 1st, 2012 at 11:33 pm
What has happened to people coming up with there own ideas. Wow is all I can say.
Ode
December 2nd, 2012 at 5:48 am
With her Spot on performance of Elizabeth Taylor in Liz and Dick, why don’t they consider Lindsey Lohan? This is a joke, but actually that would be awesome.
Brittany Coleen
December 2nd, 2012 at 9:18 am
To those that are in love with the original movie, I’m with you all the way! However, just YouTube or iTunes Carrie Underwood and listen to her voice! Coming from someone who has seen her in concert twice, it is her real voice! She is incredible! She is a great person also, so that’s an added bonus! So she won’t slander the wholesomeness of the original movie because she shares the same values as the original cast!
Just try it, YouTube/ iTunes “Jesus take the wheel” or one of her new songs “Blown Away”…. You know you wanna! ;)
Emmi
December 2nd, 2012 at 1:02 pm
OMG pls listen to the public- read some social media and save your money on this production
dodi
December 2nd, 2012 at 4:40 pm
Remember that Maria was not a beauty she was a plain girl from a poor background. I feel that the love story works better between her and the Baron if she is plain because his love interest at the beginning is an Aristocrat and his love for Maria grows from his respect for her love for his children. So I would favour a plain looking actress with a great voice.
TroyM
December 10th, 2012 at 2:35 am
Carrie’s definitely got the pipes and I’ve loved her from day one on AI… but I don’t like her in this role. I think too much will be made of her singing voice and not enough on her acting skills. Two suggestions: NPH (in drag, of course… and don’t laugh… he’s got a good set of vocals on him and he’s got the acting thing down… he’s been doing Doogie Howser since he was 15 for Pete’s sake!) or Anne Hathaway (she just filmed Les Miz and proved she’s got the vocal skills, plus she was Julie Andrews’ granddaughter in “Princess Diaries”… how poetic is that??)