Filed under: Dan, TV Shows
Author: Dan
Date: Jun 5, 2009
So last night SYTYCD announced their top twenty, ten girls and ten guys, to showcase their best dance skills for America’s votes. From the original 172 contestants who made it through to Vegas week, the night began with 32 contestants – 16 guys and 16 girls, which were eventually narrowed down to our top 10 guys and 10 girls.
For the remainder of the season Kevin and I will be giving you our play-by-play each week, talking about the guys and the girls respectively, and the things we loved and hated and everything in between. Once they start dancing as couples we’ll write up one article, but for now- here’s my take on the ladies.
[Publisher's Note: All pictures courtesy of Fox and photographed by our friend, Mike Ruiz]

Janette Manrara was the first contestant to face the judges. With little shown of this beauty before Vegas week, this ballroom dancer auditioned in Miami just a few days after her boyfriend of four years ended their relationship. According to Debbie Allen, based on the Vegas rounds, she felt that Janette would get America’s votes if she made it through to the top 20. We’ll have to see as she was the first person put through to the top ten girls!
Click on the picture below to SYTYCD: Season 5 gallery
Next to be called in to the judges was Diana, who brought her lucky monkey with her to Vegas week?! Her nervousness was too obvious, and I have to admit I’m not a fan of when people discuss their awkwardness/nerves in front of the judging panel. Sadly, for Diana, her monkey didn’t bring her the luck she was looking for as she didn’t make it through to the top 20.
At this point we had some random Asian girl – she didn’t make it, nor did they even say her name. Dang is all I have to say about that!

Kayla Rodomsky was the four girl to face the judges, and was hoping to be the second girl put through to the top ten girls. Kayla auditioned in Denver, where she showed up with her grandparents. She went straight through to Vegas, and shined her way through every round of choreography. Thankfully this blonde bombshell with her pearly whites connected with Mia Michaels as a dancer, as she is also part of the top ten girls! She is my first prediction of being one of the final two girls left in the competition when finale time rolls around.

Paris Torres was the third girl put through into the top ten. Her fire-hot looks and gorgeous curls make her a sure vote based on instant sex appeal. As for her dancing, I still don’t have a personal gauge on this one as she managed to coast straight into the top ten girls without a lot of on-air time. Clearly there is something to be said for good dancers who don’t bring a lot of attitude or drama as part of their tryouts. Well done Paris.

Jeanine Mason is another aloof mystery girl who slid into the top 10 girls without a lot of air time. From the small clip of her dancing while her name was read out as one of the top twenty I had an instant flash back to my favourite dancer from last year, Kourtney, who was eliminated just shy of making it into the top three. My random guess is Jeanie will be a surprise to a lot of people when she takes to the stage.

Karla Garcia is thankfully recognizable from Vegas week, with her minimal air time during the jazz routine, expressing how quick Tyce Diorio’s routine was. Is that enough to capture America’s attention and have them remember who she is? I’m skeptical. Unfortunately, my prediction is Karla will be one of the first three girls eliminated based on the lack of stage presence.

Caitlin Kinney was the next girl announced by the judges as through to the top ten girls. My heart is dead set on Caitlin coming out victorious this year. Her joint story of trying out alongside her sister (although in separate cities) and their dancing together throughout Vegas week tugged at my rugged heart strings. Her dance skills are amazing, and I truly feel the emotion she projects every time she takes the stage. Caitlin is my second prediction for making it through to the final two girls, and I’ll go out on an early limb and say she just may win it all.

Melissa Sandvig, who I shall refer to as ‘the dirty ballerina’ moving forward also made it through to this year’s top ten girls. I was a huge fan of her initial try out, as I have an aching heart for any girl on toe point; however, I just don’t feel she has the staying power to adapt to the dance styles that will be thrown at her (I’m foreseeing a krumping disaster), nor to earn America’s votes.

The next girl to face the judges was Ashley Belario. It was her fourth time auditioning for the show, and sadly, I still didn’t recognize her! At this point in the episode I paused my PVR to write her blurb. I just looked up and the way I have paused the screen she looks just like Tila Tequila – not good! (Sorry, random side note). Mary Murphy saw a fighter in Ashley, a lot of improvement, beautiful dancing, and the final stop – all because she made it through to the top ten girls!

Randi Evans was next on the judges list for making it into the top ten girls. Her blue leotard was especially distracting, and unfortunately I saw a lot of similarities in the headband department to that of Nathaniel from this last season’s American Idol. If you don’t recall, please Google it – you’ll see what I mean. Randi also auditioned in Denver (in the same blue bodysuit I might add – not a good choice), showcasing her dancing abilities as a lyrical dancer. I’m pretty sure Nigel’s attraction was to the bodysuit more than the actual dancing. Mia Michaels even refers to Randi’s leotards as part of her personality, as the basis for her spirit and confidence. With that, she was sent through to the top ten. After all the judges rambling, I was struggling to place who she reminded me of. Then it hit me, a trashier version of Kerrington Paine from last season!
Two more girls whose names we’re not mentioned, nor can I remember them from random inserts throughout Vegas week, were also eliminated. Unfortunately, the short-haired girl I felt had strong potential across all dance styles (from what I remember), and felt could have been a dark horse in the competition. Sadly, now I’ll simply remember her as “dark horse”. Too bad.

The final two girls to approach the judges together, vying for the final ladies spots were ballroom dancer Asuka Kondoh and contemporary dancer Dina. The tearful address to the cameras was genuinely endearing, and I’m sad that both girls won’t be on the show. Dina rocked every round of the choreography and I loved her attitude in Napoleon and Tabitha’s Hip Hop routine. Asuka’s another dark horse in this competition, fierce in her ballroom style and impressive in all the other styles throughout Vegas week. So who goes home? Through very little suspense, Dina was sent home (hopefully to return next season)! My final prediction is Asuka could surprise us all, completely dependent on the styles drawn from the hat each week.
Brett
June 5th, 2009 at 11:45 am
I’m sorry, but Kourtney was your fave contestant last year?? She was a poorly trained cheerleader who always carried so much tension in her hands I was worried she was going to knock herself out during one of her cheesy reach-and-grab lyrical solos.
I haven’t been watching this season so far (I am planning on watching starting next week during the live performances) so I was hoping this article would help me know who to watch out for…but after that confession I think I’ll just wait and see for myself.
I must say I am surprised that Natalie (Katie’s friend from last year) didn’t make it! I thought she’d be the first person put through after that whole ordeal last season.
Rich
June 5th, 2009 at 12:06 pm
Go Asuka! <3
Donovan
June 5th, 2009 at 12:22 pm
I have to admit, none of the girls have made a great impact for me as of yet. I was totally on Team Natalie before she got unceremoniously cut. BOO PRODUCERS & JUDGES.
Out of this lot, I like Asuka, Caitlin & Ashley (I have a soft spot for people who keep trying and then eventually make it).
Belle
June 5th, 2009 at 1:29 pm
Why would you predict that Karla is one of the first three to be kicked out because of the lack of stage presence? She didn’t even get that much airtime yet for you to actually make that comment.
Adam
June 5th, 2009 at 3:55 pm
I’m SO into Asuka and Caitlin… freakin’ gorgeous and christ on a cracker, those bodies! They’re definitely my two big pics!
LOVE the review Dan! Can’t WAIT for the next installment.. and hella rawsome photos mr. Ruiz ;)
Jason C-K
June 5th, 2009 at 5:18 pm
I like Caitlin, but she reminds me of the weird love child of LeAnn Rimes and Rebecca DeMornay a la “The Hand That Rocks the Cradle”…!
Brett
June 5th, 2009 at 10:15 pm
Ok wait, was your fave girl last year Courtney Galliano (girl who was in the top 4) or Kourtney Lind? Because I think you mean Courtney, not Kourtney.
Kourtney was blonde and one of my favourites going in to the top 20, and Courtney was terrible and I couldn’t believe she made it so far.
Just wanted to double check, because my reply was edited to say that I didn’t care for Kourtney, which is not true. I didn’t care for Courtney. Haha. Confusing.
Dan
June 7th, 2009 at 12:17 pm
Thanks Brett – you are absolutely right – I meant Courtney. I can’t believe you didn’t like her! She was a stunning dancer. As for blonde Kourtney – I don’t remember her. Sorry!
Belle – As for my comment on Karla, I was simply making a prediction. I could be entirely wrong, but that’s the beauty of predictions!
Kodie
June 8th, 2009 at 8:42 am
Is it just me or does Paris not look like Jay leno’s tranny lovechild?
Michael
June 9th, 2009 at 2:13 pm
I have to also disagree with the Karla Garcia prediction! She didn’t get much airtime at all except that she was one of the Denver auditionees that made Sonya get all emotional and that’s a good sign – despite them not showing her entire Black Bird routine. I hate that 50% of the Top 20 didn’t get airtime and it shows in current popularity already.
Also, Karla is a member of the Boogie Bots from America’s Best Dance Crew, pair that with her expertise in Jazz/Contemporary and you have a serious competitor! Oh, she’s also HOT!
Dan
June 9th, 2009 at 10:22 pm
Michael – thanks for the extra bio info on Karla! I had no idea she was part of the boogie bots from America’s Best Dance Crew. Also a favourite show of mine!
I’m holding strong to my prediction, although I may be proven wrong…