For our latest Who’d You Rather battle, I thought I’d switch things up a little. Instead of pitting just two guys together, I decided a handful of hot guys would be spicier. What’s their common thread? They all dated the same woman… Sophia Bush at one point or another.

The former One Tree Hill actress sure has a knack for enticing hot men to woo her. She also likes to sh*t where she eats. Three of her long-term relationships involved her OTH co-stars. That must’ve been an awkward set during all the bed hopping. Seeing a recent pic of the actress with her current beau inspired this post. Check out her dudes below and cast your vote on Who’d You Rather afterward.

Chad Michael Murray

Together: 2003-06

The first One Tree Hill co-star to sample Sophia’s “bush” was Chad Michael Murray who BTW now goes by Chad Murray. The two dated for almost two years before tying the knot. Their marriage ended five months after the wedding. Bush tried to annul it but was denied, but was granted a divorce instead. Before their divorce was finalized, Murray started dating a cheerleader on set. Murray’s television credits include Southland, Gilmore Girls and Dawson’s Creek. The 31-year-old’s notable big screen appearances are A Cinderella Story and House of Wax. He can next be seen in A Madea Christmas scheduled to hit theaters later this year.

Jon Foster

Together: 2006-07

Can we say rebound? Jon Foster and Bush dated briefly after her divorce. Rumor has it, he wanted to walk down the aisle but she wasn’t ready. Once bitten, twice shy. Jon has a brother who’s also in the industry, Ben who appeared on Six Feet Under. Jon is the poster child for failed rookie shows. The 28-year-old starred in Life As We Know It, Windfall and Accidentally on Purpose. All of which never saw a second season.

James Lafferty

Together: 2008-09

The second One Tree Hill star to go “bush”wacking was James Lafferty who was Chad Michael Murray’s character’s onscreen brother. News of Lafferty and Bush’s relationship was revealed publicly by Murray himself. Since The WB show ended, the 27-year-old has appeared in mostly films. His credits include movies I’ve never heard of: Lost on Purpose; Sam; The Legend of Hell’s Gate: An American Conspiracy and Citizen Soldiers.

Austin Nichols

Together: 2009-12

Austin Nichols completed Bush’s OTH hat trick. The two were on and off for roughly four years. Reportedly, he took the job with One Tree Hill to be closer to Bush. The 33-year-old’s notable films include Wimbledon, The Day After Tomorrow and The House of Usher. He most recently appeared in FOX’s ill-fated The Mob Doctor.

Dan Fredinburg

Together: 2013-present

Realizing relationships with actors weren’t probably the best for her, Sophia decided to go all tech-y with her new beau. Dan Fredinburg is a program manager for Google. The two were first spotted together enjoying this year’s Coachella Festival.

Who’d You Rather

Who'd You Rather: Sophia Bush Edition

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

For me personally, I would pick Austin Nichols. Love the slightly curly hair. Runner-up would be her current boyfriend Dan Fredinburg. We could shop talk in bed about getting articles higher up on the search results 😉 How about you? Sound off below.